Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Great quote. Chomsky has an amazing talent for really getting to the heart of issues and framing them in useful and insightful ways.


I find your finding of insight in this quote to say more about the challenge of AI than the quote itself ;-).

First, the quote directly contradicts itself. The first paragraph says that physicists alone hand their hard problems to others. The second describes how the chemists, biologists, and psychologists all also hand their hard problems to others.

Second, it ignores how nearly all fields of human endeavor hand of various kinds of hard problems to other fields. Software engineers hand off many hard problems to the mathematicians, philosophers, artists, hardware engineers, and sometimes even to other software engineers in adjacent levels in the software stack ;-). Similar relationships exist between archaeologists, anthropologists, paleontologists, geologists, climatologists, meteorologists, and so on. It's easy to think of examples.

Geologists can't hand all of their hard problems off to climatologists, but physicists can't hand all of their hard problems off to chemists either.

And yet, somehow, humans are able to perceive meaning from quotes like this. Our ability to read a quote, ignore what it actually says and figure out what we think it was meant to say is truly stunning.


I watched 'The manufacture of consent' recently, I had a hard time stopping listening to him. His wording dug right through my skull, very concise yet simple.


He's the most concise when it comes to explaining complicated ideas. Einstein said something about simple explanations but not too simple. The biggest point Chomsky made to me was that no real explanation or discussion can be had when you are limited to 2 minute soundbites on TV. I won't give his example but he said "You can't say <extremely flammatory counterculture yet objectively true statement> and not take the time to explain why."




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: