Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

What a tripe! There are a lot of cultures where scapegoats were never present (India and China come to my mind). Polarizing figures with leadership qualities polarize the people around them. That doesn't make them founders! They are two different sets which intersect sometimes.

And Bill Gates is NOT being forced to do charity, especially not by those who criticized him before. Most people in third world countries idolized him when geeks hated his guts.

Theil shows that he is an ahole and too much wealth has just reinforced his petty view of the people around him.



Er...Gandhi typifies almost everything Thiel is talking about.

Extreme outsider to extreme insider to victim.


How about Buddha? At no point was he an outcast or object of hatred for normal people. He was at every point supported in his quest.

More I think about it, more I realize that it is western culture of 'our way or the highway' that Theil is talking about. Point to note that the killer(s) of Gandhi were a fan of Nazis.


He started as both insider and outsider, as he was a rich lawyer, was taught at UCL, but found it hard to fit in with the culture of London.


India never had scapegoats? Really? What about the caste system then? And if you don't think China did, then go read the Book of Lord Shang.


Caste system - I knew it will be the first reply.

So why don't YOU tell me how caste system was a scapegoat? How come a system of stratification be about an individual leader?


You can scapegoat groups or individuals, the word itself applies in both contexts. If you want to find examples of scapegoating of individuals in India, then that isn't particularly hard either. Not that India is special in this regard.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: