> Honest question: are we sure that it doesn’t do logical reasoning?
It's not the Creature from the Lagoon, its an engineering artifact created by engineers. I haven't heard them say it does logical deduction according to any set of logic-rules. What I've read is it uses Markov chains. That makes sense because basically an LLM given a string-input should reply with another string that is the most likely follow-up string to the first string, based on all the texts it crawled up from the internet.
If internet had lots and lots of logical reasoning statements then a LLM might be good at producing what looks like logical reasoning, but that would still be just response with the most likely follow-up string.
The reason the results of LLMs are so impressive is that at some point the quantity of the data makes a seemingly qualitative difference. It's like if you have 3 images and show them each to me one after the other I will say I saw 3 images. But if you show me thousands of images 24 per second and the images are small variations of the previous images then I say I see a MOVING PICTURE. At some point quantity becomes quality.
It's not the Creature from the Lagoon, its an engineering artifact created by engineers. I haven't heard them say it does logical deduction according to any set of logic-rules. What I've read is it uses Markov chains. That makes sense because basically an LLM given a string-input should reply with another string that is the most likely follow-up string to the first string, based on all the texts it crawled up from the internet.
If internet had lots and lots of logical reasoning statements then a LLM might be good at producing what looks like logical reasoning, but that would still be just response with the most likely follow-up string.
The reason the results of LLMs are so impressive is that at some point the quantity of the data makes a seemingly qualitative difference. It's like if you have 3 images and show them each to me one after the other I will say I saw 3 images. But if you show me thousands of images 24 per second and the images are small variations of the previous images then I say I see a MOVING PICTURE. At some point quantity becomes quality.